PINK FLOYD
- CD
|
|
|
SOUND 8.5 / PACKAGING 9
/ PERFORMANCE 9.5
TRACK LIST: | |
|
|
REVIEW: | |
|
I thought this was found to be a fake. Comment by Keith+Venturoni wrote on 2008-05-07 13:35:59 gonna need a little more context around 'fake' Keith. It certainly could be a common bootleg misrepresentation and NOT be from an acetate. that I couldn't comment on but wouldn't be surprised as there is really no surface noise and the fidelity of the transfer could/should be a little better if it's a direct lineage. That's why it seems to have a bit of generational 'loss' to me. Still good though. Comment by Svengi wrote on 2008-05-07 13:40:40 I shared this on HungerCity and it was removed by the resident Floyd expert who said that the Floyd community had found that it was not an acetate but a phony manipulation of the actual album. Also, I believe the 8 track version of POTW was recorded after the album was finished, so it wouldn't be available for an "early mix." Comment by Keith+Venturoni wrote on 2008-05-07 14:53:05 great info and dialogue here. Regarding 8-track version of POTW, that's certainly what I understood also - recorded after the LP was in the can, or the extra solo to connect the two pieces anyway. So - there is enough evidence that this isn't what it's marketed as. An Acetate/early mix. At the very least it's suspect for sure. Thanks Keith. Comment by Svengi wrote on 2008-05-07 15:28:48 |
The best toys are the ones that are both educational and multi-purposeful.
Great Toys For Tots
Don't miss our new Top Vinyl List of the Departed
you’ll find something to tickle your fancy and your ears
|
May 1, 2008 - 10:05:30 PM